Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jason Gulya's avatar

This mostly jibes with my own experience. My students find the AI feedback useful, but don't want that over a teacher's feedback at all.

Expand full comment
Stephen Fitzpatrick's avatar

The best feedback I’ve been able to do is to use AI to interleave my comments into a coherent narrative. I generally go through and leave thorough comments throughout a Google Docs piece of writing using the comment tool. Then I download the piece into a PDF with the comments intact and use that as the basis of the AI feedback. With a detailed prompt, it will incorporate my observations into a comprehensive narrative and focus on what I highlighted and add other examples It’s a lot of extra work and not something I do for most assignments - useful for rough drafts with no grade attached. The results have been good.

Expand full comment
9 more comments...

No posts